Comparison of the Yamaha XV 535 and XVS 650 with 34 hp
Natural resources
Here the dainty, cute XV 535, there the heavy metal Drag Star – related, united in earth, but as different as chopper and cruiser.
Chopper or cruiser – that is the question here and now. Gone are the days when the friends of two-wheeled ground cover people hung amicably on wondrously curved handlebars and divided the landscape with dry front wheels. More and more often in their leisurely activities they meet conspecifics who are unmistakably brothers (and sisters) in spirit, but who have just as unmistakably deviated from the pure doctrine of chopping, roll towards their salvation with open arms on heavy, thick-soled equipment . Counter cruising.
Chopper or cruiser – that is a question that Yamaha answers “yes” in a Solomonic manner. This commitment to as well as is manifested in the drag star that was added to the notoriously successful XV 535.
Put side by side, the ideological differences between the genres materialize conspicuously. The XV 535 is unmistakably committed to the basic law of chopper construction, to minimalism, to the art of omission: its dissected body with the tightly laced wasp waist between the tank and seat cushion lets the engine and spoked wheels optically dominate, making the XV 535 a motor-wheel.
The Drag Star is different. She country homage to the motto "bigger is better", makes herself long and wide, is thick, presents her engine rather casually, and with her bulk seems to bet on the surprise effect that such a chunk can move forward on its own.
Can he? Finally his engine was drained and relieved of six horsepower so that the Drag Star could prove its suitability in the 34 horsepower class. A rough calculation does not bode well at first: 231 kilograms of machine weight plus driver, distributed over 34 horse backs – that almost calls the animal rights activists to the scene.
But the circumcised drag star does not have a protective hand, she needs a hard right hand with strong reverse torque: Only with the tap fully turned can she be persuaded to be the usual urgency – which unfortunately is in stark contrast to the cruiser’s claim to combines dynamism and serenity bring. Because there can be no talk of serenity when the Drag Star is running under full sail: the engine looks equally strained as it is listless, and it defends itself against sustained high speeds with violently whirring footrests, which thus take on a kind of speed limiter function.
The XV 535 engine is not a cheering lathe either, but it cleverly uses its displacement deficit to its advantage. With less stroke and reduced bore, the smaller of the two V2s reacts more cheerfully to marching orders, revs up more willingly, makes less fuss about its task of preparing 34 hp, wastes less energy setting its surroundings in motion.
The well-designed engine and a weight advantage of 35 kilograms make it possible for the XV 535 to duped its big sister Drag Star: When accelerating, she has the longer breath at the top, which ultimately also helps her to achieve a more respectable top speed. And to top it off, the chopper doesn’t even give the larger-capacity cruiser the title of cellar master who opens a barrel in the depth of the rev range without a fight.
As if this weren‘t enough of humiliation, the drag star must also pay tribute to her penchant for size when it comes to driving behavior. When driving straight ahead, the twisting front wheel turns out to be a ruts detector; in slow turns, the front section with a flat steering head angle asserts an energetic say in the alignment, and the footrests become plowshares even at moderate bends. It’s good that at least the brakes are able to bring the Drag Star back to the ground at the speed it deserves.
The XV 535 is not fundamentally different, but consistently better. Because it clearly lost out in terms of weight, wheelbase and front tire width, the Drag Star has a long nose in terms of handling. More predictable when it comes to keeping in lane, more precise steering behavior, more relaxed and easier to drive in an inclined position, the 650 shows you where you’re going at all times – until you scratch the notches and warn you to be careful.
It looked completely different after the first fitting. No trace of a casual, relaxed sitting posture on the chopper, on the contrary: knees and elbows strongly bent, thighs struggling for contact with the tank, hands on those strange wheelbarrow handles – it couldn’t be that. On the other hand, living more beautifully on the 650: space to stretch your legs a little, the right distance from the handlebars, a tank that offers hold and support – it should be bearable. It can be done, but no longer than on the 535. Here and there, after an hour’s drive at the latest, the desire for a cigarette break awakens, not (only) because the nicotine level has dropped, but because the back (or a lament from the back seat)) signals that it is time to stretch your legs again. Because here as there the sitting posture is firmly cemented, because here and there rear wheel suspension works, which understand their task as a striking connection between the road and the bottom line.
S.But now, at the latest, the drag star is on its way. With her full body, leaning casually on the side support, she quickly becomes the focus of onlookers’ interest and finally gives the cruiser pilot the certainty that he has made the right choice. The chopper driver sees it with serenity – hardly noticed, but with the reassuring certainty that he has found the better natural resource.
My conclusion
Chopper or cruiser – for me that is not a question of the better or worse motorcycle. If only it was possible, there was no getting around the XV 535. The long-serving bestseller is the more agile, dynamic motorcycle, with which you can have a lot of fun even away from the smoothly rolled, dead straight boulevards. No, if movement close to the ground is already the order of the day, then it is on heavy, respectful equipment that offers my 1.80 meters sufficient living space and meets my penchant for exhibitionism. So despite all factual reservations, the Drag Star – not with 34, but with 40 hp. After all, things should go a little forward not only during the show, but also when driving. After all, why do you have a whole-value 1?.
Related articles
-
Yamaha XVS 1100 Drag Star review
Yamaha XVS 1100 Drag Star review Moby Quick According to popular belief, cruisers are overweight, poorly motorized and have lousy chassis. Live on calmly…
-
Review Yamaha XVS 1100 A Drag Star Classic
Review Yamaha XVS 1100 A Drag Star Classic Heavy in motion Cruiser. Isn’t that those sluggish motorcycles with bad brakes and dusty designs? Nice ?? but…
-
Comparison test of sporty enduros
Comparison test, KTM 620 LC 4, Suzuki DR 650 SE, Triumph TT 600 Sporty enduros Too good for tough sports use and too rough for everyday life: KTM 620 LC4…
-
Comparison test single cylinder
Comparison test single cylinder Fish is looking for a bike From now on, single parties are even more interesting because the Sachs Roadster stirs up the…
-
Comparison test Yamaha Drag Star – Honda Shadow
Yamaha Drag Star / Honda Shadow test comparison Soft tissues If you want to be tough, you have to have soft parts: Long after the Honda VT 600 Shadow, a…
-
Top test Yamaha FZ1 / Fazer Let’s start now? We had to wait a long time for that : a naked Nippon athlete. Not rinsed soft, but light, firm and stable….
-
BMW R 1200 R and Yamaha YZF-R6 same performance class
Exit with BMW R 1200 R and Yamaha YZF-R6 Grumpy bear and screamer With 123 and 119 hp, the BMW R 1200 R and the Yamaha YZF-R6 belong in the same…
-
BMW R 1200 RS and BMW HP2 Sport in comparison
BMW R 1200 RS and BMW HP2 Sport in comparison Air-cooled versus water-cooled Content of The BMW HP2 Sport is a high-performance athlete, the BMW R 1200…
-
Yamaha XV 1600 Wild Star review
Yamaha XV 1600 Wild Star review Names are smoke and mirrors It’s called Road Star in America, Wild Star in Europe. But it doesn’t matter, because the…
-
Triumph Speed Triple and KTM Super Duke in comparison
Comparison test: Triumph Speed Triple and KTM Super Duke Between heaven and hell No, it really doesn’t work, the front wheels don’t want to stay on the…
Related articles
-
MotoGP – Moto GP Qatar – FP1 practice: Lorenzo and Rossi dominate the recovery –
Top test Honda VTX 1800 Dick and Schwof Under the guise of a clumsy cruiser hides something that the world has never seen before. A thunder bolt that is…
-
MotoGP – Moto GP: Livio Suppo suspects Rossi of having premeditated the collision of Assen –
Yamaha XVS 1100 Drag Star review Moby Quick According to popular belief, cruisers are overweight, poorly motorized and have lousy chassis. Live on calmly…
-
MotoGP – German GP: Rossi and Lorenzo eclipse the competition! – MotoGP: the big fight!
Bimota SB 6 R test shorts Bella bestia With the pre-series, the devil was in the details. Import Konemann promised a remedy . Does the beautiful predator…
-
MotoGP – Moto GP Qatar – W-up: Marquez in the lead, Rossi and Lorenzo cold! –
Horex VR6 Roadster in the top test Anything but mainstream Styling, sound and of course the engine concept with VR six-cylinder make the Horex VR6…
-
Comparison test of 400 enduro sports Master hunter With the 400 EXC, KTM took the Enduro World Championship title last year. The Euro-Fighter for 2000 is…
-
MotoGP – Mercato MotoGP: Ducati keeps Dovizioso alongside Lorenzo –
Suzuki M 1800 R Intruder Endurance test interim balance Cast off for a long-term trip with the Über-Cruiser, which has the thickest pistons in series…
-
MotoGP – Moto GP Qatar – FP1 practice: Lorenzo starts 2013 knocked out! –
Honda VTR top test 1000 F SILENT STAR The VTR 1000 F prefers to leave appearances in the glaring limelight to others, instead promising unexcited driving…
-
MotoGP – Czech R. GP FP3: Lorenzo wins Rossi and Marquez –
Moto Morini Scrambler 1200 in the driving report New work, revised models New work, revised models, fresh energy: Moto Morini is back. Five years after…
-
MotoGP – Moto GP Australia: Lorenzo world champion 2012 –
Ducati 1198 S test Most powerful twin of all time Now it’s happened. With the 1198 S, Ducati is not only sending the most powerful twin athlete of all…
-
MotoGP – Rossi Vs Marquez: Lorenzo rejected in his request to intervene before CAS –
Aprilia RS 250 test comparison against Honda NSR 250 Sports mirror Aprilia versus Honda – Italy versus Japan . The tough Grand Prix duel of…