Facebook group trial on radars: decision in September
Members of the "Facebook group that tells you where the police are in Aveyron", sentenced in the first instance to a one-month license suspension for having reported and shared on the social network the location of the radar checks in the department, will have to wait for the September 21 to be fixed on their fate…
Members of the "Facebook group that tells you where the police are in Aveyron", sentenced in the first instance to a one-month license suspension for having reported and shared on the social network the location of the radar checks in the department, will have to wait for the September 21 to be fixed on their fate…
Article R413-15 of the Highway Code |
I. – The fact of holding or transporting an appliance, device or product of a nature or presented as being of such a nature as to detect the presence or disrupt the operation of devices, instruments or systems used to detect infringements of legislation or the regulation of road traffic or allowing to evade the finding of said offenses is punishable by the fine provided for contraventions of the fifth class.
The fact of using a device, device or product of the same nature is punishable by the same penalties. II. – That device, device or product is seized. When the apparatus, device or product is placed, adapted or applied to a vehicle, that vehicle may also be seized. III. – Anyone guilty of the offense provided for in this article also incurs the following additional penalties:
Any conviction automatically gives rise to the confiscation of the device which was used or was intended to commit the offense.. IV. – This contravention automatically gives rise to a reduction of two points of the driving license. |
Last year, the Rodez court (12) estimated that the activity of this group – which today counts no less than! – constituted an "evasion of the observation of traffic offenses".
Yesterday, after two hours of debate, the Montpellier Court of Appeal (34) decided to put the case under advisement and will deliver its judgment on September 21, 2015.
"Device"
Legally, the court of appeal (then possibly the court of cassation) will have to rule on whether a Facebook group can be likened to a "apparatus, device or product" as stated by article R413-15 of the highway code (opposite).
"The Advocate General representing the prosecution requested confirmation of the decision of the Rodez Criminal Court on the guilt of the defendants, but requested a modification of the sentences according to the personality of the latter", explains Jean-François Chancheur , lawyer for one of the group members.
"We insisted on the fact that the provisions of article R413-15 of the highway code could not target a Facebook page as a device aimed at evading the finding of traffic offenses", continues the lawyer who pleads "the reversal of the decision and thus supported the release of all the defendants".
For its part, the Automobility and Future (A&A) think tank recalls that this affair "could have implications, beyond Facebook, on all on-board tools and on any new technology designed to support drivers in their daily lives. ".
"Hypocrisy"
A&A wonders if it would not be "time to put an end to the hypocrisy in this matter, even though information tools for danger zones, having the same functionalities, are marketed with the consent of the State. ". Recall that to maintain their legality, these speed camera warning devices had to be considerably degraded by their manufacturers (read MNC of May 12, 2011:, MNC of July 29, 2011: and MNC of October 25, 2011:).
This type of group – which could be described as public utility insofar as they allow precise knowledge of danger zones on the road – is very successful on social networks and on Facebook in particular: nearly 15,000 members for Aveyron, more than 10,000 "likes" in Vienne, more than 53,000 in Ile-de-France, etc.
Through these "calls for digital lighthouses", national solidarity also plays on Twitter with the hashtag, since even the National Police warns users of the locations of radar controls in the Alpes-Maritimes (opposite) !
To be continued on MNC in our special reports, and: stay connected…
Related articles
-
Speed cameras – Speed cameras: a senator wants to ban their reporting –
Speed cameras : a senator wants to ban their reporting It was to be expected: with the bad figures for road fatalities (+ 30.4% in September), ever…
-
Radars – The Facebook group on radars released in cassation –
The Facebook group on the radars released in cassation The Court of Cassation has just released the Facebook group that tells you where the police are in…
-
Speed Cameras – Some invisible police checks on alarms like Coyote and Waze –
Some invisible police checks on alarms like Coyote and Waze The interministerial delegate for road safety, Emmanuel Barbe, announces that he wants to put…
-
Speed cameras – New features for the Coyote driving assistant –
New features for the Coyote driving assistant The boxes and the Coyote application evolve as the summer crossroads approach: notification of motorway…
-
Speed cameras – Automatic speed cameras may no longer be reported –
Automatic speed cameras may no longer be reported It was, however, foreseeable: by electing the main instigator of automated sanction control to the…
-
Speed cameras – Speed camera warnings in the government’s sights –
Radar warnings in the government’s sights Thwarted by the development of user communities using radar warnings, the government is threatening to make…
-
Radars – Speed cameras: the noose is tightening on European drivers –
Radars: the noose is tightening on European drivers After Switzerland, Luxembourg, Belgium and Spain, the Netherlands have just joined the list of…
-
Speed cameras – Soon on your roads: automatic double-sided speed camera! –
Soon on your roads: automatic double-sided radar ! A new model of automatic speed camera is appearing on the roadside: double-sided speed camera! Because…
-
Speed cameras – Gray boxes on yellow roads … –
Gray boxes on the yellow roads… Gilles de Robien and Remy Heitz yesterday inaugurated in Loire-Atlantique the second wave of automatic radars, which…
-
Speed Cameras – Vehicle Confiscation! –
Vehicle confiscation ! The French Prime Minister Jean-Pierre Raffarin chaired the 3rd Interministerial Road Safety Committee yesterday in Matignon….