Table of contents
- Test: 8 silencers for the BMW R 1200 GS Accessories vs. original
- Parallels to the current car emissions scandal?
- Principle very simple
- Original unbeatable in terms of power and torque
- New noise limits from 2016
- This is how MOTORRAD tests
- BMW original
- Akrapovic slip-on
- Bos Desert Fox
- Hashiru Motegi Big
- Mivv Speed Edge
- Sebring Phantom
- Spark Force Car
- Termignoni slip-on
- Zard Penta Style
- Commentary Jorg Lohse (head of service)
- MOTORCYCLE sound app
- Final scoring
mps studio
37 pictures
Jorg Lohse
1/37
Accessory silencers are registration-free, you don’t need extra papers. But the labeling has to be correct.
mps
2/37
Spark Force Car: For bass lovers in the GS auditorium. Spark creates a very deep grumble in the stomach area. Unfortunately, the woofer also remains very present when it comes to driving noises.
MOTORCYCLE
3/37
Performance measurements: Spark Force Car.
mps
4/37
Termignoni Slip-on: The big Italo brand doesn’t really want to convince on the Bayern boxer. Weak test bench curves, throbbing sound. But at least: the lightest system in the test!
MOTORCYCLE
5/37
Performance measurements: Termignoni slip-on.
mps
6/37
Zard Penta Style: delicate tones? Not with Zard. The finely crafted exhaust storms high in the MOTORCYCLE charts. Unfortunately also with the driving noise. Lures with an attractive price!
MOTORCYCLE
7/37
Performance measurements: Zard Penta Style.
mps
8/37
The final evaluation at a glance.
Jorg Lohse
9/37
Many manufacturers currently adhere to the dB limit with flap controls.
Jorg Lohse
10/37
Stricter limit values will apply from 2016. Whether that will continue to work with a flap?
Jorg Lohse
11/37
Loud or quiet? Phonetically correct measurement aria on the MOTORRAD top test area.
Jorg Lohse
12/37
Achievement or Loser? On the MOTORRAD test bench, only one exhaust wins this time.
Jorg Lohse
13/37
Screw or fail? Even amateur hobbyists are not overwhelmed with the extension.
Jorg Lohse
14/37
Moo or muh? During the sound check, some exhaust pipes fail miserably in their voices.
archive
15/37
MOTORRAD service boss Jorg Lohse (46) has doubts about the new measuring method.
archive
16/37
Click on www.motorradonline.de/auspuff, download the app, record sounds, listen to them, share them.
Jorg Lohse
17/37
These are the sound charts from Jorg Lohse, part of the test crew: 1. Spark, 2. Zard, 9. Hashiru.
MOTORCYCLE
18/37
Performance measurements: Sebring Phantom.
mps
19/37
Sebring Phantom: Clearly the Phantom of the Opera in this test. Sebring ensures enthusiastic applause in the MOTORRAD listening room. When it comes to driving noises, however, there is no applause.
MOTORCYCLE
20/37
Performance measurements: Mivv Speed Edge.
Jorg Lohse
21/37
Even if, as with Mivv Titan, it says on the shell: The inner workings of the silencers are usually made of heavier stainless steel.
Jorg Lohse
22/37
Thanks to the one-piece construction with a neatly welded connecting pipe, many systems can be installed in a matter of minutes.
Jorg Lohse
23/37
With BOS, the sound can be tuned using an adjustable resonance plate. Nothing changes in terms of performance and volume.
Jorg Lohse
24/37
Anyone who loosens this screw has bad cards not only at police checks. In the course of the noise debate, he damages the whole scene.
Jorg Lohse
25/37
Perfect for a tension-free fit when the holder screwed to the silencer can still be adjusted.
Jorg Lohse
26/37
Clamps that are fiddly to attach are still accepted for cheap parts (Hashiru), not in the 1000 Euro league (Termignoni).
Jorg Lohse
27/37
Scorched weld seams, not deburred. . . The points of criticism years ago, but no longer an issue in this test field. Good this way!
mps
28/37
BMW Original: decent performance, not that expensive at all. And even in the original version, the GS sounds like a boxer. The BMW exhaust sets the bar in the test damn high.
MOTORCYCLE
29/37
Performance measurements: BMW Original.
mps
30/37
Akrapovic Slip-on: Extremely noble made end piece from the Slovenian cult forge, which gives the GS more steam around the bottom and sounds great. Borderline: the driving noise!
MOTORCYCLE
31/37
Performance measurement: Akrapovic slip-on.
mps
32/37
BOS Desert Fox: scores with a small increase in torque in everyday life, but has to take a lot with the driving noise. The test listeners were also disappointed in the sound rating.
MOTORCYCLE
33/37
Performance measurements: BOS Desert Fox.
mps
34/37
Hashiru Motegi Big: Polo’s house brand may be tempting with its incredibly low price, but cannot set any accents in terms of quality. Weak performance, plus a slack soundscape.
MOTORCYCLE
35/37
Performance measurements: Hashiru Motegi Big.
mps
36/37
Mivv Speed Edge: When it comes to design, the finely crafted GS edition from Mivv is convincing. Those who rely on real values, on the other hand, will be disappointed. PS values in the minus, weak sound.
Jorg Lohse
37/37
These are the sound charts from Sebastian Schmidt, part of the test crew: 1. Sebring, 2. Akrapovic, 9. Termignoni.
accesories
Exhaust & silencer
Eight silencers for the BMW R 1200 GS in the product test
Test: 8 silencers for the BMW R 1200 GS
Accessories vs. original
Loosen the screw and clamp – and you are holding the silencer of the BMW R 1200 GS in your hand. A replacement part can be installed in a matter of minutes. But is it worth using the accessory exhaust? Who offers more performance, who sounds best? Eight providers compete against the Munich original.
Jorg Lohse
15/10/2015
To the fanfares, Mr. Kapellmeister, a flourish: As nimble as with the BMW R 1200 GS we haven’t been able to carry out an exhaust test in recent years. Because replacing the rear silencer is usually only a matter of minutes and does not pose any major challenges even to laypeople working with the tool box. Above all, a clever flap construction in the outlet section makes the screwdriver action incredibly easy.
Buy complete article
Test winner silencer for the BMW R 1200 GS (MOTORRAD 22/2015)
Akrapovic slip-on
8 pages) as PDF
€ 2.00
Buy now
A look back: In the past, an electronically controlled exhaust flap that existed in the original had to be either completely dismantled or at least shut down on almost every test motorcycle. Only then could an accessory pot be attached. In the current BMW R 1200 GS, on the other hand, the exhaust flap is placed at the manifold outlet in front of the connecting pipe and remains in normal operation with every replacement silencer.
Parallels to the current car emissions scandal?
Of course, everyone flinches when they hear the word flap control – and of course parallels are quickly drawn to the current emissions scandal in cars. Of course, the first question that arises is whether such a construction is legal at all. Because the main purpose of the flap on motorcycles is to ensure that the legally relevant driving noises are complied with. These are currently still measured according to EU regulation 97/24 / EC, which will be replaced by UNECE-R 41 from next year.
So far, the driving noises have been measured when accelerating from 50 km / h in second and third gear over a distance of 20 meters. According to the law, the phonometer can record a maximum of 80 decibels on average from all passages. A really sharp figure when you consider that a stormy autumn day already touches your ears with the same number of phoning numbers. Even with many moderately powered motorcycles, a flap is therefore essential in order to achieve this value.
Principle very simple
The principle is very simple. To effectively contain the driving noise, a flap in the exhaust tract is closed via servomotors and cables from a speed of 50 km / h. Depending on the acceleration values, the flap is opened again from 70 km / h upwards – with the effect, of course, that the number of decibels increases accordingly. In contrast to the current emissions affair, the motorcycle systems we know are not designed for pure test bench runs. The flap works in any case – regardless of whether the bike is rolling through town at 50 or is being moved as part of a noise measurement.
This means that it is completely legal, according to experts from various testing organizations from TuV or Dekra, if they are entrusted with the homologation of the corresponding systems. The extent to which this will change from 2016 onwards is currently still speculative. This practice has long been a thorn in the side of noise opponents when it comes to tuning silencers: How can it be that the motorcycles only have to be so quiet in the measuring range, but the phon values may explode before or after the legally stipulated limits? Which is why they have great hopes for the realignment of the noise measurement regulations. With the complex measuring process and additionally lowered decibel values, the aim is to make the currently common flap tuning – quiet only between 50 and 70 km / h – impossible. However, it remains to be seen whether this actually works.
Original unbeatable in terms of power and torque
So let’s first take a look at the current test situation. And in this a completely dramatic picture emerges. Because anyone who thinks that he has made nimble legs with the quick muffler change on his BMW R 1200 GS will rub his eyes in amazement. The bitter truth on the MOTORCYCLE test bench: Not an accessory exhaust reaches the peak values in terms of power and torque that are delivered by the original.
Many at least deliver values at series level, some others, on the other hand, have to give in. Up to five percent less peak performance. That is anything but what you would expect from an accessory pot. At least a weight advantage can still be achieved. Instead of the standard part equipped with reflection chambers, the accessory pots filled with insulating wool can save up to 50 percent mass. And of course the sound makes the music. It’s hard to describe. That’s why you hear the GS overture to the test in this video.
New noise limits from 2016
Jorg Lohse
Stricter limit values will apply from 2016. Whether that will continue to work with a mouth?
Track closures, noise symposia, environmental initiatives against motorcycle crashes. The biker scene is currently grappling with this situation. It will be exciting in a few weeks. The new noise guideline UNECE-R 41 should turn the tap off from 2016 onwards. From 80 dB (A), which is currently permitted as driving noise, then a maximum of 77 dB (A) – to be complied with, of course, only for new motorcycles.
As usual, older guys enjoy grandfathering. The previous measurement method will also change. Essentially, the sound level permitted according to the new regulation is calculated from various measurements with constant speed and full load acceleration. Experts from various testing organizations believe that the new method will undermine the previous practice of regulating noise using flap controls. However, such systems are not generally prohibited – only if they are activated via test cycle detection.
This is how MOTORRAD tests
Jorg Lohse
Loud or quiet? Phonetically correct measurement aria on the MOTORRAD top test area.
At the regulars’ table, it is quickly clear what characterizes a good replacement silencer: It has to sound as bold as possible! Which is why this purely subjective impression is also answered in the test. Of course, it has no influence on the pure scoring. For this, only the hard facts are decisive, which are collected in the everyday MOTORRAD test routine. After the flying visit to the workshop (initial assembly) and photo studio, it’s off to the field tests.
The top test site at Neuhausen ob Eck airfield is ideal for checking compliance with the noise limits stipulated in EU regulation 97/24 / EC. The Dynojet test bench clarifies whether the boxer wins – or loses – punch with the accessory silencers.
BMW original
mps
BMW original.
Providers: BMW Motorrad, Tel. 0 89/1 25 01 62 00, www.bmw-motorrad.de
Materials: stainless steel
Price: 637.51 euros
Weight: 4.9 kg
Suitable from year of construction: 2013
Country of Manufacture: Poland
ECE approval mark: 1 (Germany)
Versions / extras: chrome-plated 828.78 euros
Design type: Slip-on
Standing noise dB (A) *: 94
Driving noise dB (A) **: 82
Weight: 4.9 kg
Perfomance: 88.7 kW / 121 PS
Sound: Fed up
Plus: best performance in test; rich sound; valuable processed; precisely fitting and easy to assemble.
Minus: high weight
Conclusion: Decent performance, not that expensive at all. And even in the original version, the BMW R 1200 GS sounds like a boxer. The BMW exhaust sets the bar in the test damn high.
MOTORRAD verdict: Good
* measured at half the nominal speed, permissible according to approval documents 93 dB (A);
** measured according to Directive 97/24 / EC, legally permissible 80 dB (A)
Akrapovic slip-on
mps
Akrapovic slip-on.
Providers: GP Products, Tel. 0 69/96 75 95 50, www.gpproducts.de
Materials: titanium
Price: 1004 euros
Weight: 4.4 kg
Suitable from year of construction: 2013
Country of Manufacture: Slovenia
ECE approval mark: 24 (Ireland)
Versions / extras: Stainless steel / titanium manifold 594/792 euros
Design type: Slip-on
Standing noise dB (A) *: 93
Driving noise dB (A) **: 86
Weight (compared to the original): minus 11.2 percent
Performance (compared to the original): minus 0.2 percent
Sound: fat
Plus: Torque increase in the lower range; top processed; rich, independent sound; to be assembled precisely, exemplary assembly instructions
Minus: high driving noise; high weight; very expensive
Conclusion: Extremely elegant tail from the Slovenian cult forge, which gives the BMW R 1200 GS more steam around the bottom and sounds great. Borderline: the driving noise!
MOTORRAD verdict: Good
* measured at half the nominal speed, permissible according to approval documents 93 dB (A);
** measured according to Directive 97/24 / EC, legally permissible 80 dB (A)
Bos Desert Fox
mps
Bos Desert Fox.
Providers: BOS Exhaust, Tel. 0 59 41/47 93, www.bosauspuff.de
Materials: stainless steel
Price: 799 euros (carbon look)
Weight: 4.6 kg
Suitable from year of construction: 2013
Country of Manufacture: Netherlands
ECE approval mark: 4 (Netherlands)
Versions / extras: matt 799 euros / black 899 euros
Design type: Slip-on
Standing noise dB (A) *: 90
Driving noise dB (A) **: 89
Weight (compared to the original): minus 7.1 percent
Performance (compared to the original): minus 0.3 percent
Sound: shrill
Plus: small increase in torque in the lower range; neatly and nicely processed; custom-fit assembly
Minus: very high driving noise; high weight; slack sound without depths
Conclusion: BOS scores with a small increase in torque in everyday life, but has to take a lot of driving noise. The test listeners were also disappointed in the sound rating.
MOTORRAD verdict: Good
* measured at half the nominal speed, permissible according to approval documents 93 dB (A);
** measured according to Directive 97/24 / EC, legally permissible 80 dB (A)
Hashiru Motegi Big
mps
Hashiru Motegi Big.
Providers: Polo Motorrad, Tel. 0 21 65/8 44 04 00, www.polo-motorrad.com
Materials: stainless steel
Price: 299 euros
Weight: 3.3 kg
Suitable from year of construction: 2013
Country of Manufacture: Italy
ECE approval mark: 9 (Spain)
Versions / extras: –
Design type: Slip-on
Standing noise dB (A) *: 91
Driving noise dB (A) **: 87
Weight (compared to the original): minus 32.9 percent
Performance (compared to the original): minus 4.8 percent
Sound: sapless
Plus: very light, low price
Minus: very high driving noise; eats power and torque; very fiddly first assembly with universal retaining clip; dull sound
Conclusion: Polo’s house brand attracts with an unbelievably low price, but cannot set any accents in terms of quality. Weak performance, plus a slack soundscape.
MOTORRAD verdict: satisfying
* measured at half the nominal speed, permissible according to approval documents 93 dB (A);
** measured according to Directive 97/24 / EC, legally permissible 80 dB (A)
Mivv Speed Edge
mps
Mivv Speed Edge.
Providers: Motogrip, Tel. 03 66 95/34 31 45, www.mivv-auspuff.de
Materials: Stainless steel / titanium
Price: 820 euros
Weight: 3.0 kg
Suitable from year of construction: 2013
Country of Manufacture: Italy
ECE approval mark: 9 (Spain)
Versions / extras: Stainless steel 600 euros, black 660 euros
Design type: Slip-on
Standing noise dB (A) *: 88
Driving noise dB (A) **: 85
Weight (compared to the original): minus 39 percent
Performance (compared to the original): minus 3.8 percent
Sound: bland
Plus: very easy; handsome and neatly processed; custom-fit assembly
Minus: high driving noise; eats power and torque; slack sound without depths; very expensive
Conclusion: When it comes to design, the finely crafted GS edition of Mivv to convince. Those who rely on real values, on the other hand, will be disappointed. PS values in the minus, weak sound.
MOTORRAD verdict: Good
* measured at half the nominal speed, permissible according to approval documents 93 dB (A);
** measured according to Directive 97/24 / EC, legally permissible 80 dB (A)
Sebring Phantom
mps
Sebring Phantom.
Providers: Mizu Vertiebs GmbH, Tel. 0 77 31/9 06 70, www.mizu.de
Materials: stainless steel
Price: 635 euros
Weight: 3.4 kg
Suitable from year of construction: 2013
Country of Manufacture: Austria
ECE approval mark: 4 (Netherlands)
Versions / extras: –
Design type: Slip-on
Standing noise dB (A) *: 94
Driving noise dB (A) **: 87
Weight (compared to the original): minus 30.9 percent
Performance (compared to the original): minus 0.9 percent
Sound: robust
Plus: pleasantly bassy and very independent sound; easy; neatly processed; to assemble quickly and precisely
Minus: very high driving noise; Standing noise above the registered value
Conclusion: Clearly the phantom of the opera in this test. Sebring ensures enthusiastic applause in the MOTORRAD listening room. When it comes to driving noises, however, there is no applause.
MOTORRAD verdict: Good
* measured at half the nominal speed, permissible according to approval documents 93 dB (A);
** measured according to Directive 97/24 / EC, legally permissible 80 dB (A)
Spark Force Car
mps
Spark Force Car.
Providers: Parts Europe, Tel. 0 65 01/9 69 50, www.partseurope.eu
Materials: Stainless steel / carbon
Price: 643 euros
Weight: 3.1 kg
Suitable from year of construction: 2013
Country of Manufacture: Italy
ECE approval mark: 3 (Italy)
Versions / extras: Stainless steel 571 euros
Design type: Slip-on
Standing noise dB (A) *: 93
Driving noise dB (A) **: 87
Weight (compared to the original): minus 37.0 percent
Performance (compared to the original): minus 2.4 percent
Sound: massive
Plus: rich, bass-heavy sound; easy; very well processed; to assemble quickly and precisely
Minus: very high driving noise; no installation instructions
Conclusion: For bass lovers in the GS auditorium. Spark creates a very deep grumble in the stomach area. Unfortunately, the woofer also remains very present when it comes to driving noises.
MOTORRAD verdict: Good
* measured at half the nominal speed, permissible according to approval documents 93 dB (A);
** measured according to Directive 97/24 / EC, legally permissible 80 dB (A)
Termignoni slip-on
mps
Termignoni slip-on.
Providers: Jamparts FZG Technik, Tel. 0 71 50/97 05 65, www.jamparts.com
Materials: Titanium / carbon
Price: 938.91 euros
Weight: 2.9 kg
Suitable from year of construction: 2013
Country of Manufacture: Italy
ECE approval mark: 11 (UK)
Versions / extras: Stainless steel / carbon 808.01 / 1022.21 euros
Design type: Slip-on
Standing noise dB (A) *: 89
Driving noise dB (A) **: 82
Weight (compared to the original): minus 45.1 percent
Performance (compared to the original): minus 4.2 percent
Sound: soft
Plus: extremely light; very cleanly processed; exact, tension-free fit
Minus: eats power and torque; dry, slightly clattering soundscape; Universal clamp difficult to assemble; very high price
Conclusion: The big Italo brand doesn’t really want to convince on the Bayern boxer. Weak test bench curves, throbbing sound. But at least: the lightest system in the test!
MOTORRAD verdict: Good
* measured at half the nominal speed, permissible according to approval documents 93 dB (A);
** measured according to Directive 97/24 / EC, legally permissible 80 dB (A)
Zard Penta Style
mps
Zard Penta Style.
Providers: BOS exhaust, Tel. 0 59 41/47 93, www.zardauspuff.de
Materials: Matt stainless steel / carbon
Price: 699 euros
Weight: 3.6 kg
Suitable from year of construction: 2013
Country of Manufacture: Italy
ECE approval mark: 13 (Luxembourg)
Versions / extras: Carbon 799 euros, titanium 779 euros
Design type: Slip-on
Standing noise dB (A) *: 92
Driving noise dB (A) **: 87
Weight (compared to the original): minus 26.8 percent
Performance (compared to the original): minus 0.7 percent
Sound: thundering
Plus: very cleanly processed; easy and precise to assemble; light weight; beautiful sound
Minus: very high driving noise, no installation instructions
Conclusion: Delicate tones? Not with Zard. The finely crafted exhaust storms high in the MOTORCYCLE charts. Unfortunately also with the driving noise. Lures with an attractive price!
MOTORRAD verdict: Good
* measured at half the nominal speed, permissible according to approval documents 93 dB (A);
** measured according to Directive 97/24 / EC, legally permissible 80 dB (A)
Commentary Jorg Lohse (head of service)
archive
MOTORRAD service boss Jorg Lohse (46) has doubts about the new measuring method.
Gear weighting, reference acceleration, partial load factor …, phew: the new noise regulation UNECE-R 41 will regulate how loud motorcycles can be on almost 50 bureaucratically claused pages. The number 77 decibels hovers ominously above all – three less than before. Whereby the old and new limit values are not comparable. What used to be measured at 80 dB (A) can suddenly be five decibels quieter with the new method – on paper! Which is why I also doubt that there will be more calm in the future with the new regulation. Even after 2016, there will still be motorcycles that are perceived as too loud by the environment. Because outside the measuring range, there is still no defined maximum value that must be adhered to.
Perhaps it would have been brave to finally sweep the established measurement method, which is also the basis of the new regulation, completely off the table. And to tackle a solution that really cuts noise peaks. On some racetracks it’s very simple: Maximum dB value at half the rated speed – if you are above it, you stop. Period. But then presumably a phone number would have been on the paper that would have led to an outcry among motorcycle opponents at round tables and in citizens’ groups: What, so loud? One thing is clear: noise harms us all. Which is why only the feeling in the right hand will really ensure peace.
MOTORCYCLE sound app
archive
Click on www.motorradonline.de/auspuff, download the app, record sounds, listen to them, share them.
In the future, the free sound app from MOTORRAD (for iOS and Android smartphones) will quickly clarify whether your own bike is convincing in terms of sound. The principle is very simple: Download the app, easily record your own exhaust sound and share it with the community. You can also use the search function to search for exhaust brands and motorcycle types.
Final scoring
mps
The final evaluation at a glance.
Gone are the days when almost every accessory silencer was superior to the original part in many respects. Tuning by exhaust – that’s history. In the meantime, you have to be happy that the muffler alternative still achieves the series values at all. In this test, only Akrapovic and BOS can maintain the performance level of the BMW R 1200 GS in the original setting. Mivv, Spark and Termignoni at least win on the scales – the latter also scores with convincing values in the noise measurements. In the last column there are sometimes horrific prices. 700 euros and more for a simple muffler? That already seems heavily exaggerated.
Related articles
-
Product test: accessory silencer for BMW S 1000 RR
Photos: BMW accesories Exhaust & silencer Product test: accessory silencer for BMW S 1000 RR Product test: exhaust systems for BMW S 1000 RR What do…
-
A comparison test of ten silencers for the Kawasaki Z 800
mps studio 30th pictures Lohse 1/30 Certification mark: If the exhaust is correctly marked (E-check digit plus four-digit numerical code, 5 or 9 circled…
-
Test winner silencer for the BMW R 1200 GS (MOTORRAD 22-2015)
mps studio accesories Exhaust & silencer Test winner silencer for the BMW R 1200 GS (MOTORRAD 22/2015) Test winner silencer for the BMW R 1200 GS…
-
12 silencers for the BMW R 1200 GS in the test
Lohse 41 pictures Lohse 1/41 3rd place: Hattech Dark Style The Hattech muffler not only gives the GS a powerful sound, but also scores with a…
-
Product test: retrofit silencer for Kawasaki Z 750
jkuenstle.de accesories Exhaust & silencer Product test: retrofit silencer for Kawasaki Z 750 Product test including videos about the exhaust systems…
-
Hertneck accesories Exhaust & silencer Exhaust test BMW K 1200 S Exhaust test BMW K 1200 S Investment advice When it comes to top performance, there is…
-
Product test retrofit silencer for Suzuki Bandit 1250-S
Artist accesories Exhaust & silencer Product test retrofit silencer for Suzuki Bandit 1250 / S Product test retrofit silencer for Suzuki Bandit 1250 / S…
-
Product test: motorcycle jeans
Lohse 17th pictures Lohse 1/17 Of course, there is only one thing that can realistically test whether the jeans clothes really hold up: a fall. Since no…
-
Sdun clothing Station wagons, jackets & pants Product test: textile jackets Product test: textile jackets Jackets for winter Icy outside, cozy and warm…
-
Product test: exhaust systems for the Kawasaki Z 1000
jkuenstle.de accesories Exhaust & silencer Product test: exhaust systems for the Kawasaki Z 1000 Product test: exhaust systems for the Kawasaki Z 1000…