Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock

Table of contents

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
mps photo studio

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock

20th pictures

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
Tobias Beyl

1/20
The Triumph Street Triple RS kept quiet while we put her tank bag on tank bag. Important to you and us: scratch something on the tank?

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
Tobias Beyl

2/20
Vanucci and Hepco & Becker requested the drill, but also allowed individual positioning.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
Ferdinand Heinrich

3/20
Just in case: Givi (also IXS and Kappa), Hepco & Becker and SW-Motech (also Vanucci) offer the ring counterpart as a spare part, Oxford even the entire base plate.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
mps photo studio

4/20
1st place: SW-Motech Pro Daypack. SW-Motech does almost everything right with the new Pro-Line.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
mps photo studio

5/20
The bag and magnetic ring are of the highest quality, only the small amount of moisture spoils the very good overall impression of the test winner.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
mps photo studio

6/20
2nd place: Givi ST 605 B TanklockED: With the new ST 605 B, Givi delivers a stable everyday companion, four screws and one click are sufficient for assembly.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
mps photo studio

7/20
Givi: The red lever to release is a bit stiff.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
mps photo studio

8/20
Here the Givi with its removable mobile phone holder.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
mps photo studio

9/20
Also 2nd place: Kappa RA 309 R Tanklock. Kappa delivers a sturdy bag with many useful details and very good functionality.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
mps photo studio

10/20
The tank bag from Kappa and Givi rightly shared second place in the test: the same ring system, very similar features.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
mps photo studio

11/20
4th place: iXS Astor. The lightweight of iXS with Givis system shows potential for improvement here and there, but gives a good overall impression.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
mps photo studio

12/20
At this competitive price, a clear purchase tip: 69.95 euros for the iXS tank bag and 15.95 euros for the tank ring.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
mps photo studio

13/20
5th place: Vanucci tank bag Evo. Vanucci’s bag comes with the SW-Motech system and scores with a freely selectable position.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
mps photo studio

14/20
Like Hepco & Drilling is a curse and a blessing for Becker, while the little wetness is more of a curse.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
mps photo studio

15/20
6th place: Hepco & Becker Royster. With drilling and waterproof inner bag, Hepco goes & Becker different ways than most participants.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
mps photo studio

16/20
Hepco & Becker: There are definitely advantages to this, but it also calls for a few small compromises.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
mps photo studio

17/20
7th place: Oxford Q4R. Oxford scores with many extra features and means it very well, for example with the viewing window cover.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
mps photo studio

18/20
However, the implementation leaves room for improvement. Moisture protection is rather nil.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
mps photo studio

19/20
8th place: Shad E10P. Slim and adjustable, this bag is a discreet, simple companion.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
mps photo studio

20/20
The pin system, albeit stable, did not convince us: the tank is in danger of scratching, the bag came off with little weight.

accesories

Luggage

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock

Tank bags with Quick-Lock being tested
8 combinations of ring and bag

Slowly but surely, magnets and straps can pack, the tank rings conquer the bag market. We are testing 8 tank bags with quick release fasteners.


Mona Pekarek

04/30/2021

In this article:

  • Givi ST 605 B TanklockED
  • Hepco & Becker Royster
  • IXS Astor
  • Kappa RA 309 R tank lock
  • Oxford Q4R
  • Shad E10P
  • SW-Motech Pro Daypack
  • Vanucci tank bag Evo
  • Conclusion

Quick-Lock – or quick release – is without a doubt the easiest and fastest way to attach a tank bag to a motorcycle. In terms of payload and off-road capability, it is limited, but an absolute recommendation for the day tour. We have eight combinations of ring and bag exemplarily on ours Endurance test motorcycle Triumph Street Triple RS tested. Exemplary because the manufacturers offer model-specific rings. In addition, the steering angle and seating position on other motorcycles can be different and thus provide slightly different impressions in driving behavior. The system from Givi (IXS, Kappa) is used three times. SW-Motech not only competes with the brand new Pro-Ring, but indirectly through Vanucci also with the Evo-Ring. How they fare against the other three systems and what differences there were in bag handling, you will find out below.

Buy complete article

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock

Tank bags with Quick-Lock being tested
8 combinations of ring and bag in comparison

4 pages) as PDF

€ 2.00

Buy now

Givi ST 605 B TanklockED


Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


mps photo studio

With the new ST 605 B, Givi supplies a stable everyday companion, four screws and one click are sufficient for assembly.

Price: 133.99 euros (bag), 14.99 euros (ring attachment); Volume: 5 liters; Weight: 1.1 kilograms (weighed; bag including all ring parts); required tool: hexagon socket; Rain cover: hood with viewing window, both wet tests passed; Color: Black; Features: removable mobile phone holder, small reflectors on the sides, lockable fastening, handle with rubber coating, lockable zippers, removable glasses compartment, shoulder strap, cable duct, second mesh compartment in the lid

Quick and easy assembly, understandable instructions, high-quality hard shell, two inner chambers, ring with pocket lockable, easy to carry away from the motorcycle (handle, strap), efficient shape, inherently stable.

Red lever for releasing a bit stiff, not expandable, few compartments, position cannot be selected, therefore viewing the mobile phone is difficult, the pocket is particularly noticeable on the arms and upper body when driving sportily.

Conclusion: With the new ST 605 B, Givi supplies a stable everyday companion, four screws and one click are sufficient for assembly. Since the position cannot be selected, it loses points, especially when it comes to driving behavior.

MOTORRAD verdict: very good

Hepco & Becker Royster


Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


mps photo studio

With drilling and waterproof inner bag, Hepco goes & Becker different ways than most of the participants.

Price: 169 euros (bag), 45.95 euros (ring); Volume: 5 to 8 liters; Weight: 1.1 kilograms (weighed; bag including all ring parts); Required tools: hexagon socket, drill, drill; Rain protection: waterproof inner bag with roll closure, slight weak point in the wet test; Colors: black, black-yellow; Features: large reflectors, handle, lockable zippers, expandable volume, two inner compartments in the lid, eyelets for mobile phone holder (not included)

Comprehensible instructions with photos, sturdy outer shell, easy attachment of the bag with magnets, efficient shape, volume expandable, stable, position freely selectable through your own drilling, thus only slightly noticeable on the arms and upper body.

Installation time slightly longer due to drilling, corner to ring broke after repeated use, zipper on main compartment stiff, inner bag increases effort, minimal moisture penetration.

offers

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


H&B Tail bag Royster waterproof 27-32 liters black / gray

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
Delivery time: 1-2 working days

€ 190.00
plus € 3.49 shipping


To the shop

Conclusion: With drilling and waterproof inner bag, Hepco goes & Becker different ways than most participants. This has its advantages, but it also requires a few small compromises.

MOTORRAD verdict: Good

IXS Astor


Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


mps photo studio

The lightweight of IXS with Givis system shows potential for improvement here and there, but gives a good overall impression.

Price: 69.95 euros (bag), 15.95 euros (ring attachment); Volume: 5 liters; Weight: 0.7 kg (weighed; bag including all ring parts); required tool: hexagon socket; Rain protection: rain hood with viewing window, both wet tests passed; Color: Black; Features: viewing window for the smartphone, expandable volume, cable passage, handle and shoulder strap, lockable zippers, reflective seams

Quick and easy assembly, integrated mobile phone compartment, solid workmanship, main compartment easily accessible and efficient, easy to carry away from the motorcycle (handle and strap), very low weight.

Lid rather soft, this makes it difficult to attach, only one compartment, inherently unstable, position is predetermined, so the bag is clearly noticeable on the arms and upper body, moderate view of the smartphone, the film wrinkles, the red lever is a bit stiff to release.

offers

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


IXS tank bag Tanklock Astor, black

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
Delivery time: 3 – 5 days

€ 69.95
plus € 3.99 shipping


To the shop

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


IXS Astor, tank bag Tanklock – black

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
Delivery time: immediate

€ 69.00
plus € 5.90 shipping


To the shop

Conclusion: The lightweight of IXS with Givis system shows potential for improvement here and there, but gives a good overall impression. At this competitive price a clear buy tip.

MOTORRAD verdict: Good

Kappa RA 309 R tank lock


Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


mps photo studio

Kappa delivers a sturdy bag with many useful details and very good functionality.

Price: 108 euros (bag), 15 euros (ring attachment); Volume: 5 liters; Weight: 1 kilogram (weighed; bag including all ring parts); required tool: hexagon socket; Rain protection: rain hood with viewing window, both wet tests passed; Color: Black; Features: detachable smartphone holder, reflective seams, small outer pocket, lockable zippers, two chambers inside, rubberized handle and shoulder strap, cable duct

Quick and easy assembly, high-quality hard shell, good compartment system, efficient shape, easy to carry away from the motorcycle (handle and strap), inherently stable, curves benefit driving behavior.

Red lever for releasing a bit stiff, position cannot be selected, making it difficult to see the smartphone, cannot be extended, noticeable on the arms and upper body during sporty driving.

Conclusion: Kappa delivers a sturdy bag with many useful details and very good functionality. She rightly shares second place in the table with Givi: the same ring system, very similar features.

MOTORRAD verdict: very good

Oxford Q4R


Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


mps photo studio

He scores with many extra features and means it e.g. B. very good with the viewing window cover, but the implementation leaves room for improvement.

Price: 90 euros (bag according to the manufacturer), 23.90 euros (ring attachment); Volume: 4 liters; Weight: 1 kilogram (weighed; bag including all ring parts); required tool: hexagon socket; Rain protection: waterproof seams, unfortunately leaks during irrigation; Colors: Black, Blue, Red; Equipment: viewing window with cover for smartphone, reflectors, key compartment, can also be used as a rear pocket thanks to the separable bottom, rubberized handle, cable outlet, seat belt for handlebars

Large viewing window, quick and easy assembly, handle easy to use even with gloves, practical key compartment, separable bottom allows use as a tail bag

Stiff zippers, making the main compartment difficult to access, leaking, the cover of the viewing window rather in the way, builds high up, thus contact with the upper body, ring must be hit exactly, ring sharp-edged if the bag is not installed

Conclusion: Oxford scores with many extra features and means it very well, for example with the viewing window cover, but the implementation leaves room for improvement. Moisture protection rather nil.

MOTORRAD verdict: satisfying

Shad E10P


Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


mps photo studio

The pin system, albeit stable, did not convince us: the tank is in danger of scratching, the bag came off with little weight.

Price: 112.99 (bag), 29.99 euros (tank pins with plate); Volume: 5 liters; Weight: 1 kilogram (weighed; bag including all ring parts); Required tools: hexagon socket, Torx; Rain cover: rain hood, both wet tests passed; Color: Black; Features: viewing window for the smartphone, various positions possible, mini bag and elastic inside, cable passage, small reflectors, lockable zippers, seat belt, handle and shoulder strap

Only pins instead of a ring are not bulky, four selectable positions, so hardly noticeable when driving, main compartment easily accessible, easy to carry away from the motorcycle (handle and strap), good view of the smartphone.

Pins have to be hit exactly, otherwise the plate scratches the tank, only engages properly with weight and a lot of pressure, holds moderately, loading is difficult due to the curvature in the lid.

offers

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


SHAD PIN SYSTEM TANK BAG E10P

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
Delivery time: immediate

€ 93.71
plus € 3.99 shipping


To the shop

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


Shad Pin System tank bag X0SE10P 5 liters of storage space

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
Delivery time: 1-2 working days

€ 94.99
plus € 3.49 shipping


To the shop

Conclusion: Slim and adjustable, this bag is a discreet, simple companion. The pin system, albeit stable, did not convince us: the tank is in danger of scratching, the bag came off with little weight.

MOTORRAD verdict: satisfying

SW-Motech Pro Daypack


Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


mps photo studio

SW-Motech does almost everything right with the new Pro-Line.

Price: 135 euros (bag), 30 euros (ring); Volume: 5 to 8 liters; Weight: 1.1 kilograms (weighed; bag including all ring parts); required tool: hexagon socket; Rain protection: waterproof hood, slightly leaking during filling test; Color: Black; Features: Volume expandable, position adjustable via guide rails, Molle carrying system on top, reflectors, mesh compartment and elastic straps inside, lockable zippers, double cable outlet

Position individually adjustable, therefore hardly noticeable when driving, simple locking by magnet, firm hold, very smooth zippers, main compartment very accessible, volume expandable, high-quality materials, stable ring, practical Molle carrying system on top

: Rain cover slightly leaking, red belt creates a waterway into the inside of the bag, the ring has to be screwed together at great expense, the rail takes up a lot of space inside

offers

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


SW-Motech rain cover – as a replacement for PRO Daypack tank bag.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
Delivery time: immediate

€ 10.00
plus € 3.99 shipping


To the shop

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


SW-Motech Backpack PRO Daypack Magnetic tank bag for motorcycles with steel tank

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
Delivery time: available – in 2-3 working days with you

€ 135.00
plus € 4.95 shipping


To the shop

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


SW-MOTECH PRO magnet tank bag daypack 6-9 liters of storage space

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
Delivery time: 1-2 working days

€ 135.00
plus € 3.49 shipping


To the shop

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


SW-Motech Pro Daypack 6-9 L, magnetic tank bag – black

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
Delivery time: 1-3 working days

€ 135.90
plus € 5.90 shipping


To the shop

Conclusion: SW-Motech does almost everything right with the new Pro-Line: The bag and magnetic ring are of the highest quality, and the small amount of moisture alone tarnishes the very good overall impression of the test winner.

MOTORRAD verdict: very good

Vanucci tank bag Evo


Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


mps photo studio

Vanucci’s bag comes with the SW-Motech system and scores with a freely selectable position.

Price: 119.99 euros (bag), 30 euros (ring); Volume: 7 to 9 liters (indication, appears smaller); Weight: 1 kilogram (weighed; bag including all ring parts); Required tools: hexagon socket, drill (included), drill; Rain protection: waterproof hood, slightly leaking during filling test; Color: Black; Features: Volume expandable, large viewing window, double cable opening, mesh compartments and elastic bands inside, lockable zip, handle, reflectors, shoulder strap

Detailed instructions, sturdy tank ring, large card / cell phone compartment, position can be individually selected by drilling, thus hardly noticeable when driving, expandable volume, easy to carry away from the motorcycle (handle and strap), good view of cell phone or map.

Lid doesn’t hold open on its own, shape restricts loading, rain cover slightly leaks, lid rather unstable, assembly by drilling significantly more complex, fasteners hook easily.

offers

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


SW-Motech pull strap for EVO tank bag – 12 cm. Spare part for EVO City, GS, Micro, Engage.

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
Delivery time: 5 – 7 days

€ 2.00
plus € 3.99 shipping


To the shop

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


SW-MOTECH Drybag for tablet on tank bag

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
Delivery time: 1-2 working days

€ 20.00
plus € 3.49 shipping


To the shop

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock


SW-Motech Drybag, tablet bag waterproof – black / clear

Comparison test of 8 tank bags with Quick-Lock
Delivery time: 1-3 working days

€ 20.90
plus € 5.90 shipping


To the shop

Conclusion: Vanucci’s bag comes with the SW-Motech system and scores with a freely selectable position. Like Hepco & Drilling is a curse and a blessing for Becker, while the little wetness is more of a curse.

MOTORRAD verdict: Good

Conclusion

All bags serve their purpose. They transport a day’s stuff. And yet there were serious differences in the test. While with the somewhat water-shy test winner SW-Motech everything works smoothly and the ring clicks firmly into place, Shad, for example, with the pin solution is innovative, but a little less well thought-out. The Givi system was used three times, and with Kappa it comes in second place twice. Absolute price hit and thus our purchase tip is IXS.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *