10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test

Table of contents

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Mona Pekarek

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test

38 pictures

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

1/38
Ten magnetic tank bags in a comparison test.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

2/38
Vanucci VS03 Sportivo.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

3/38
The compartments on the top swallow up cell phones or sat navs without any problems, but are quite difficult to access.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

4/38
Wish list: A card compartment would add value to the detachable mounting plate.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

5/38
Oxford M15R.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

6/38
Even without an inner bag, the Oxford is protected against moisture, as is the cable duct.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

7/38
The glare protection makes perfect sense. The compartment holds GPS or smartphones, but no maps.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

8/38
Buse TRS Sport Touring.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

9/38
Getting used to or clumsy: the main compartment opens towards the driver.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

10/38
The recess holds a navigation system, but does not offer any fixation. Not suitable for smartphones.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

11/38
Givi XS 312.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

12/38
An inner bag protects the Givi from getting wet. Unfortunately, the elastic band doesn’t close enough.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

13/38
In addition to a very spacious map pocket, the Givi comes with a tablet pocket.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

14/38
Hero Campo Curved.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

15/38
Curved bottom that can be flexibly adapted to the shape of the tank, high-quality workmanship.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

16/38
The belt pouch for glasses or other items can be removed, but can be a nuisance while driving.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

17/38
Kappa LH 200.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

18/38
Not the best quality, but still practical: lashing straps plus backpack straps.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

19/38
The Kappa can be expanded to almost double its volume. 14 becomes 24 liters.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

20/38
Richa Space Tankbag.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

21/38
Clever: The holding plate, which can be separated with a zip, also has a card compartment.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

22/38
The rain cover is pleasantly large, the deployable navigation compartment can continue to be used.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

23/38
QBag tank bag 04.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

24/38
Many of the pockets are softly lined – good for sensitive smartphone displays.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

25/38
Two inner walls divide the storage space. They are individually adjustable thanks to Velcro.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

26/38
Bagster Modulo Tank XSR090.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

27/38
No viewing window, but can be linked to other bags in the range thanks to the belt system.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

28/38
Backpack straps are part of the standard equipment and bring the bag from the tank to the back.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

29/38
Modeka Super Bag.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

30/38
The unusual flap closure offers advantages when filling. Unfortunately only there.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

31/38
Small eyelet, big effect: As a backpack, it presses on the back, it can rub against the tank.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

32/38
Attachment type: Magnet tank bag.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

33/38
Attachment type: belt lashing systems.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

34/38
Attachment type: tank ring.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

35/38
Motorcycles often have completely different tank shapes. An old SV 650 was therefore also used as a test tool.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

36/38
Service test camp on the edge of the Col de l’Espigoulier in southern France. “Accuracy of fit” checked differently…

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

37/38
Tobias Beyl (30): 1st Oxford M15R, 2nd Givi XS312, last: Modeka Super Bag.

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test
Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

38/38
Roman Kirschbauer (31): 1st Kappa LH 200, 2nd Vanucci VS03 Sportivo, last: Modeka Super Bag

accesories

Luggage

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test

10 magnetic tank bags tested
Luggage solutions without a ring and lashing

Whether a day trip or a long weekend: a magnetic tank bag swallows significantly more than your underpants and toothbrush. There are now many innovative solutions – but not all of them are good.

Tobias Beyl, Roman Kirschbauer

07/17/2018

If you don’t feel like having a permanently installed tank ring or are tired of the annoying lashing of belt systems, magnetic tank bags are the best way to go. They can be clicked on the tank in no time at all, and they only have a strap attached to secure them, which is quickly wrapped around the steering head. But anyone who opts for magnetic adhesion should check whether the tank on their motorcycle is actually made of sheet steel. Because many manufacturers are now installing lightweight plastic tanks that are cheaper to produce, for which the specimens tested here are not an option – unless an alternative strap is included for fastening.

Buy complete article

10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test

10 magnetic tank bags in the test
Luggage solutions without a ring and lashing

6 pages) as PDF

€ 2.00

Buy now

The decision as to which model to use is only obvious at first glance. Depending on the shape of the tank, the different bags sometimes sit well, sometimes less well on the bike. In this respect, you should definitely go to the trouble and put the test to the test.

1st place: Vanucci VS03 Sportivo

Providers: Detlev Louis,
Price: 149.99 euros (RRP)
Volume: up to 22 liters
Weight: 2.1 kg


10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test


Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

Vanucci VS03 Sportivo.

Furnishing: waterproof zippers, smartphone, GPS and map pocket, three outer compartments, removable rain cape, volume expansion, magnetic and belt attachment to the base plate, shoulder strap

Positive: excellent workmanship made of very, stable and non-slip material, base plate can be separated with a zipper; sealed zippers, luggage volume is sufficient for longer tours

Negative: very high structure, depending on the shape of the tank, the stability may be limited; quite heavy The pocket for the integrated rain cape is placed in an unfortunate way and takes up a lot of storage space

Conclusion: the Vanucci VS03 Sportivo is by far the most expensive tank bag in the test, but also the best! Despite minor weaknesses, he takes test victory. However, it will simply be too big and heavy for one or the other. Still: a perfect performance, congratulations!

MOTORRAD verdict: very good

2nd place: Oxford M15R

Providers: Oxford,
Price: 119.95 euros (RRP), 91.61 euros (currently cheapest price)
Volume: 12 to 15 liters
Weight: 1.33 kg


10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test


Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

Oxford M15R.

Furnishing: waterproof zippers, GPS / mobile phone compartment, three outer pockets, removable inner bag, water-protected cable routing, volume expansion, shoulder strap

Positive: removable, watertight inner bag secured with Velcro, safety strap with double D fastener, facilitates lashing around the steering head, sealed zippers; wide support surface

Negative: Little luggage volume, little expandability, navigation compartment too small for a card

Conclusion: the Oxford Thanks to its great workmanship and useful features, the M15R achieved a “very good” rating. And yet it may be ruled out for many: There is no space for a map and, overall, not much fits into it.

MOTORRAD verdict: very good

3rd place: Buse TRS Sport Touring

Providers: Buse,
Price: 119.95 euros (RRP), 79.95 euros (currently cheapest price)
Volume: 15 to 25 liters
Weight: 1.48 kg


10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test


Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

Buse TRS Sport Touring.

Furnishing: Continuously waterproof zippers, smartphone and GPS compartment, map pocket, two outer compartments, integrated rain cape in neon yellow, volume expansion, belt attachment possible

Positive: lots of storage space, good division, several separate pockets in the main compartment; Very good moisture protection, curved bottom perfect for some tank shapes, unsuitable for others

Negative: Navi compartment without fixations, overall opulent dimensions, builds very high with increased volume

Conclusion: the Buse TRS Sport Touring consistently offers a solid performance, convinces with rainproof seams, an additional rain cape and plenty of space. However, it is also comparatively large. The magnets are sufficiently strong.

MOTORRAD verdict: Good

3rd place: Givi XS 312

Providers: Givi,
Price: 117.95 euros (RRP), 85.36 euros (currently cheapest price)
Volume: 15 to 18 liters
Weight: 1.10 kg


10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test


Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

Givi XS 312.

Furnishing: Card compartment, additional card / tablet compartment, two outer compartments, waterproof inner bag with elastic band, volume expansion, shoulder strap

Positive: modern, sporty design, additional card / tablet pocket, high-quality, lockable zippers; very good workmanship

Negative: Volume expansion is small, elastic band on the inner bag makes no sense, rain hood was not included (but it is promised)

Conclusion: the Givi XS 312 is a very high quality tank bag, which is finely processed and offers sufficient storage space. Only the questionable closure of the waterproof inner pocket and the forgotten rain cover spoil the overall impression.

MOTORRAD verdict: Good

3rd place: Held Campo Curved

Providers: hero,
Price: 109.95 euros (RRP), 98.90 euros (currently cheapest price)
Volume: 14 to 20 liters
Weight: 1.64 kg


10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test


Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

Hero Campo Curved.

Furnishing: waterproof inner bag, smartphone and GPS compartment, map pocket, belt pouch, volume expansion, shoulder strap, inclined viewing window

Positive: Curved bottom that can be flexibly adjusted to the shape of the tank, navigation compartment inclined towards the driver, separate belt pouch for glasses and stuff

Negative: Enclosed shoulder strap uncomfortable, no further outside compartments, map compartment wide but quite short

Conclusion: An externally very massive tank bag equipped with reflectors. Adheres very securely to the tank thanks to the elegantly designed base and powerful magnets. The outer material of the hero Campo Curved is extremely hard-wearing.

MOTORRAD verdict: Good

3rd place: Kappa LH 200

Providers: Kappa,
Price: 75.99 euros (RRP), 49.35 euros (currently cheapest price)
Volume: 14 to 24 liters
Weight: 1.31 kg


10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test


Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

Kappa LH 200.

Furnishing: separate map pocket, three outer compartments, rain cape, huge volume expansion, magnetic and strap attachment to the base plate, backpack straps

Positive: compact design, low structure, very easily accessible main compartment, stable carcass, hard-wearing material

Negative: Rain cover too big if the volume is not expanded (tendency to flutter), main compartment cannot be further subdivided, lashing straps look cheap

Conclusion: The inexpensive Kappa LH 200 surprised in the test with a consistently positive performance. Its enormous expandability allows it to be used flexibly. Both for the day tour and for the long weekend.

MOTORRAD verdict: Good

3rd place: Richa Space Tankbag

Providers: Motor trend,
Price: 119.90 euros (RRP)
Volume: 15 to 20 liters
Weight: 1.92 kg


10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test


Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

Richa Space Tankbag.

Furnishing: Detachable map compartment, deployable navigation compartment, two outside compartments, rain cape, retaining plate that can be detached and can also be used solo thanks to its own map compartment, shoulder strap

Positive: very thick, stable and water-repellent material, reflectors neatly integrated into the design; very powerful magnets, maps and navigation devices can be accommodated, even separately on the mounting plate

Negative: Main compartment not further subdivided, zips can only be temporarily closed, smartphone can neither be conveniently stored for storage nor for navigation

Conclusion: the Richa Space Tankbag convinces with some well thought-out features such as the map compartment in the holding plate. It is particularly suitable for those who want to use a commonly dimensioned navigation system. Others, on the other hand, tend to take up space when the GPS compartment can be set up.

MOTORRAD verdict: Good

8th place: QBag tank bag 04

Providers: polo,
Price: 79.99 euros (RRP), 69.99 euros (currently cheapest price)
Volume: 18 liters
Weight: 1.25 kg


10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test


Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

QBag tank bag 04.

Furnishing: Glasses compartment, adjustable partitions, mobile phone pockets, integrated map compartment, three outside compartments, holder for GPS mount, separate rain cover

Positive: Softly lined pocket for the smartphone with its own cable passage, compartment for (sun) glasses, two partitions in the main compartment that can be adjusted with Velcro, the two zippers of the main compartment can be secured with a push button

Negative: Fixed glasses compartment, card compartment quite small, with a sporty posture the upper body lies on the hard edge of the inner partitions

Conclusion: All in all, the QBag Tankbag 04 had a good performance. The fact that it does not do badly with 82 points, but worse than others, is due not least to the lack of an increase in volume. The favorable purchase price and flexible interior walls speak for him.

MOTORRAD verdict: Good

9th place: Bagster Modulo Tank XSR090

Providers: Shark helmets,
Price: 99.99 euros (RRP) / 89.90 euros (currently the cheapest price) plus 16.90 euros for magnetic attachment
Volume: 13 to 17 liters
Weight: 1.14 kg


10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test


Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

Bagster Modulo Tank XSR090.

Furnishing: waterproof, removable inner pocket, two outer compartments, volume expansion, lashing option with others Bagster Modulo pockets, backpack straps

Positive: compact design, sleek design, connection option with other Bagster Modulo bags, waterproof, removable inner pocket

Negative: On the construction side, it is more of a backpack with magnets than a magnet tank bag, high effort when using it for the first time: side walls have to be pushed in

Conclusion: The Bagster Modulo Tank XSR090 is a sophisticated, expandable tank bag. With its small volume, it is not suitable as a luggage bag for a big camping trip, but ideal for visiting the beach or town.

MOTORRAD verdict: Good

Place 10: Modeka Super Bag

Providers: Modeka, www.modeka.de
Price: 74.90 euros (RRP), 69.90 euros (currently cheapest price)
Volume: up to 26 liters
Weight: 1.08 kg


10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test


Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

Modeka Super Bag.

Furnishing: Map pocket, separate navigation compartment, two outside compartments, rain cover, volume expansion, backpack straps

Positive: All-round zipper allows easy access to luggage at all times, solid material; Can be used as a backpack, sufficiently large card slots

Negative: Rain cover is missing (but is promised), poor weather protection, the entire locking mechanism including the all-round zipper does not open

Conclusion: the Modeka Super Bag cuts a fine figure as a backpack, less so than a tank bag. This is mainly due to the unusual and cumbersome design of the closure. Otherwise: sufficient storage space.

MOTORRAD verdict: satisfying

MOTORRAD judgment and final evaluation

The positive verdict from this test: Whether on the round tank of an older Suzuki SV 650 or on the modern, angular design of the current Triumph Street Triple RS – all test candidates followed the physical arrest warrant – even on the highway beyond the recommended speed. In general, nobody in the test field makes a major faux pas. However, some innovative solutions run counter to the basic idea of ​​a tank bag. In addition to easily accessible main and secondary compartments, durable material and sensible rain protection, there should be enough space for a smartphone, wallet, multi-tool, chain spray and toothbrush. In the best-case scenario, the volume can be expanded without restricting the driver’s freedom of movement and without impairing driving dynamics. Still very important: viewing windows for maps or navigation systems.


10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test


MOTORCYCLE

At the end of the day, Vanucci’s magnetic tank bag won the test.

Two tank bags achieve a “very good” rating, followed by five test participants tied in third place. Overall, almost the entire field of participants can be attested to suitability for everyday use and reliability, and all participants also showed themselves to be trustworthy when it came to the subject of grip and driving stability. In this respect, all tested tank bags are suitable for small or large excursions. The main differences are in the accessibility of the compartments and the equipment, especially when it comes to moisture protection. The best buy is the Kappa LH 200 – the cheapest tank bag in the test costs just a third of the Vanucci test winner at just under 50 euros.

What would the editors use??

Tobias Beyl (30): I don’t need a card slot. For the sporty tour, my choice is the well-made Oxford M15R.

1. Oxford M15R
2. Givi XS312
Last: Modeka Super Bag


10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test


Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

Roman Kirschbauer.

Roman Kirschbauer (31): With an ultra-flexible storage volume, stable structure and few frills, I put the Kappa on my tank.

1. Kappa LH 200
2. Vanucci VS03 Sportivo
Last: Modeka Super Bag

Three types of attachment

Magnet tank bags

Fastening a tank bag using integrated magnets is usually quick and uncomplicated, but requires a sheet steel tank. Fewer and fewer motorcycles are delivered with one, however, the majority of bikes currently have a plastic tank. Magnetic tank bags are not suitable for these. In the test, the Triumph Street Triple RS was used, which has a metal tank as well as many existing motorcycles. A disadvantage of magnets: the direct and strong adhesion can cause unsightly scratches.


10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test


Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

Attachment type: belt lashing systems.

Belt lashing systems

Fastening a tank bag using lashing straps is practically the universal solution: the material of the tank does not matter, the only requirement is some way of securing the straps to the bike safely and without fluttering. As a rule, this is done using a loop around a frame tube or a boom, the other end of the strap is then clipped into the bracket provided on the tank bag. Problems arise when there is no attachment point on the frame, as can be the case with fully enclosed machines.

Tank ring

Quick release systems require neither a sheet steel tank nor fastening options for straps on the motorcycle. Depending on the provider, these tank ring systems have different names such as Quick Lock, Lock-It or Tanklock. For the fastening ring, which is firmly attached to the filler neck, around 50 euros are due in addition to the actual tank bag. In return, the tank bag can be flanged on and off conveniently in everyday life and without the risk of scratches. A disadvantage is the mostly only small size or the small luggage volume of the products.

Five questions about the ideal tank bag

1. Which system? There are three types of fastening to choose from: with magnets, lashing straps or with a tank ring. Almost more important than the system, however, is the fit: motorcycle tanks are sometimes narrow, sometimes wide, some are very long and rounded, others wide and angular. The ideal tank bag is the one that can be securely attached to the motorcycle – and that offers plenty of storage space.

2. How much volume? Ten liters: Petite tank bags are pretty, but only hold the most important items. They go great with sporty motorcycles if you want to be out and about in a leather suit without bags. Ten to 20 liters: good all-rounders for short to medium-length excursions. They hold an emergency ration of food and drinks, usually have a map or navigation compartment and also swallow chain spray and rain gear. They are also the best choice for smaller purchases. More than 20 liters: These tank bags are usually quite high and can therefore restrict visibility and freedom of movement. They are out of place for the pure attack on the country road, but they are recommended for long tours that require a lot of luggage.

3. What to pack? In the tank bag there are mainly things that you have to be able to get to quickly during a short stop: wallet, papers, cell phone, map, camera, drinking bottle, rain cover, visor cleaner, etc. Sleeping bag and gas cooker are better stored elsewhere.

4. How to stow? Basic rule: heavy pieces on the bottom, light pieces on the top. Tip: it is best to store electronic devices between cushioning parts such as a rain suit or sweater so that they are protected against vibrations. Several outer compartments and a separate compartment for smartphone, keys and wallet are useful. A divisible inner compartment is an advantage.

5. Theft protection? Even if many zips can be secured with a lock: the tank bag can usually be removed from the bike as a whole without any complications. It is therefore best to always do that. Commercially available anti-theft devices are only intended for fuel stops and coffee breaks when the bike remains in the field of vision.

This is how MOTORRAD tests

We only make judgments when we are sure. And we can only be sure when every tank bag has passed the tough test procedure.


10 motorcycle magnet tank bags in a comparison test


Beyl, Kirschbauer, Pekarek, mps-Fotostudio, Siraphol-Fotolia

Motorcycles often have completely different tank shapes. An old SV 650 was therefore also used as a test tool.

Testing a tank bag does not just mean attaching it to the motorcycle and seeing what fits in. All test candidates went through the following extensive test procedure twice with two different test editors: First, it was checked whether the features promised by the manufacturer actually exist and fulfill their purpose. We immediately tested the quality of the material, the workmanship of the seams, the accessibility of the main and secondary compartments (both on and off the motorcycle) and the usefulness of the division. Then the weight of each tank bag is determined.

We carried out driving tests on an older Suzuki SV 650 and the current Triumph Street Triple RS. Among other things, the duration and effort of the assembly, the distribution and the strength of the built-in magnets, the usability / visibility of the card compartment (if available) and the handling of the rain cover or the inner bag were checked and evaluated. While driving on winding passes in southern France and during high-speed tests on motorways in Germany, we checked the stability, slip resistance, tendency to flutter, possible obstructions to the view of the instruments and potential restrictions in freedom of movement / driving dynamics.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *